Instructions
Begin by soaking the herring in cold water for at least one hour. If the herrings taste particularly salty, consider repeating this soaking process one more time, refreshing the water to ensure excess salt is removed. Once the soaking is complete, drain the herring thoroughly to avoid excess moisture, then slice each piece into bite-sized portions—this helps the fish absorb the marinade more evenly. Place the sliced herring carefully into a jar spacious enough to hold all the pieces comfortably. Pour the olive oil over the fish until fully covered, then add the aromatic allspice, whole peppercorns, and the bay leaf for a subtle depth of flavor. Seal the jar tightly. Refrigerate the jarred herrings for 2 to 3 days to allow the flavors to meld beautifully. The marinated herring will stay fresh refrigerated for up to two weeks, making it a great make-ahead dish. When ready to serve, accompany the herring with finely chopped or thinly sliced onions, a squeeze of fresh lemon, and a sprinkle of parsley or dill. These garnishes brighten the rich flavors and add a fresh contrast. For an authentic experience, enjoy alongside hearty rye bread or crisp crackers. Tip: Use a glass or food-grade plastic container to avoid any metallic taste from reacting with the oil and spices. Also, gently shake the jar every day to evenly distribute the spices and oil for consistent flavor throughout the fish.